When it comes to depositing
federal income taxes and FICA taxes withheld from employees'
wages, the government holds employers to strict timelines.
Pay late and an IRS penalty notice is almost sure to follow.
Fail to pay
and the IRS may pursue not just the company, but also
so-called “responsible persons” — officers, employees, and
other individuals who are responsible for collecting,
accounting for, and paying the company's payroll taxes.
In Trust
Federal employment tax
withholdings are considered government property, which an
employer holds “in trust” until the money is paid to the
IRS. The penalty for
willfully failing to turn over the tax amount to
the government is known as the 100% trust fund recovery
penalty because it is equal to 100% of the unpaid taxes.
In the Hot Seat
In one recent case, the IRS was
successful in its efforts to hold a corporation's former CFO
and CEO personally
liable for the penalty. The company, which
eventually declared bankruptcy and liquidated, failed to
remit more than $5 million in payroll taxes over a period of
several years.
In granting the IRS summary
judgment, the court noted that the CFO had the authority to
direct and decline creditor payments, sign checks, oversee
general cash flow, and hire and fire employees in the
accounting department. When questioned, he admitted that he
knew that other creditors were being paid before the IRS.
The CEO held general control of
the company's operations, could hire and fire employees, and
had the authority to sign checks. Although he was told about
the tax problem, he did not take action to correct it,
instead delegating the problem to the CFO. According to the
court, “his apparent choice to turn a blind eye and a deaf
ear” to warnings that the payroll taxes were not being paid,
while shifting blame to the CFO, did not relieve him of
personal liability.
Assessment Period
The IRS may be preparing to
become more aggressive in its pursuit of the penalty. In
recent advice, the agency's chief counsel said that the
government has no time limit to assess the penalty if an
employer has committed fraud, willfully attempted to evade
tax, or failed to file an employment tax return.